Home

What is the Real Cost of Chocolate?

Your favourite chocolate bar might not taste so sweet when you consider that with each bite you are supporting an industry where children may be forced to work long hours in dangerous conditions instead of going to school.

Spotlight on West Africa
Exposing the truth
What's the chocolate industry doing about it?
What are the solutions?

Spotlight on West Africa

About 70% of the cocoa beans used to make chocolate around the world come from West Africa,
with Ivory Coast and Ghana among the biggest producers.

ACT now!
Eat guilt-free chocolate! Get the Good Chocolate Guide here...

Harvesting cocoa is intensive, back-breaking work and cocoa prices have been declining in recent years. To keep costs down, farmers traditionally use their children and other family members to help.

Criminal networks have been caught moving children across regions and international borders to work on cocoa farms. World Vision even learned of one trafficker who smuggled children into the Ivory Coast by faking a convoy of ambulances containing healthy children who were bandaged to fool authorities.

Today there are hundreds of thousands of children working on cocoa farms in the Ivory Coast and Ghana. Some of these cocoa children routinely carry heavy loads, and work with fire, chemicals and knives, with little or no protection. Many of them have no chance of going to school.

back to top

Exposing the truth

Over the last 10 years, the international media has begun to expose the use of child labour in the cocoa industry. Some media reports have claimed that in the worst cases children as young as six are being forced to work 80-100 hours a week, enduring beatings and malnutrition.

Bitter Chocolate by Carol Off
Listen to an interview with the author of Bitter Chocolate

The Ivorian government has blamed the international cocoa industry for keeping prices too low to provide decent livelihoods for farmers. The global price, determined by cocoa exchanges in London and New York, has plummeted in recent years, putting intense pressure on farmers to increase their yields. Meanwhile chocolate manufacturers and exporters have continued to make massive profits.

back to top

What's the chocolate industry doing about it?

In September 2001, members of the chocolate industry signed a voluntary protocol known as the "Harkin-Engle Protocol" after the two U.S. Congressmen that initiated the industry reform. The protocol aimed to establish credible standards of public certification that ensured cocoa production was free of forced labour and the worst forms of child labour in the Ivory Coast and Ghana.

The first steps was to survey farms representing half of the cocoa production in Ghana and the Ivory Coast and certify they were free of the worst forms of child labour. These survey results were then to be independently verified. This process was to be completed by July 2005. The industry failed to meet that deadline.

Another failed deadline

Industry was given an extension until July 2008. But now, three years later, they have missed their second deadline, failing to have the survey results independently verified by 1 July 2008. World Vision calls on the chocolate industry to say 'yes' to a detailed, fully funded plan of action for tackling labour exploitation by 1 December 2008 - read more

back to top

What are the solutions?

Ending child exploitation and trafficking in cocoa farms is not simple and it will take time. Boycotting our favourite chocolates is not the answer, as it only hurts poor farming families more. Instead, solutions will be found by working at many levels:

  • Big Chocolate manufacturers and exporters bear a lot of the responsibility in tackling this issue. They need to:
    • Reassess their supply chains so that the products we buy are child labour- and human trafficking-free and guarantee farmers a fair price for their cocoa
    • Publicly outline a time-bound Plan of Action to ensure their products are free of human exploitation. We call on them to do this by Christmas 2008 and to engage a wide group of stakeholders in the development of this plan.
  • Retailers should stock ethical chocolate (i.e. chocolate that is made from cocoa that is picked without the involvement of human trafficking or the worst forms of child labour and also guarantees a fair price for the farmer). Retailers should convey to manufacturers that the Australian public will not tolerate buying goods made by exploiting children.
  • You and I should not boycott our favourite chocolates, since this only hurts poor farming families even more. Instead, we should use our voices to demand ethical chocolate from manufacturers, and our purchasing power to support ethical chocolate.

back to top